A tissue-paper town at winter dusk with snow falling and a bell tower lit gold
|

A Carol That Wasn’t Religious

Share

How Errollyn Wallen put the unease of winter inside a tune anyone can sing.

This December, Ars Nova Singers presents Darkness & Light: A Solstice Celebration, the second concert of the 2026/27 Confluence season, conducted by Artistic Director Tom Morgan with guest artist Gavin Kitchen, principal percussionist of the Longmont Symphony Orchestra, on vibraphone and percussion. The choir sings it on Thursday, December 10 in Longmont, Sunday, December 13 in Denver (also streamed live), and Thursday, December 17 and Saturday, December 19 in Boulder. In the second half comes Peace on Earth, words and music by Errollyn Wallen, written around 2006 and now widely recorded. Its composer has since become Master of the King’s Music.

A song for herself

Round painting of crowds skating on a frozen river beside a castle and bare trees
Hendrick Avercamp, A Winter Scene with Skaters near a Castle, c. 1608–09. National Gallery, London (public domain).

Nobody commissioned Peace on Earth. Wallen had wanted for years to write a Christmas carol, and this one first lived in her own songbook. She has been direct about what she was after. “For a long time I really wanted to write a Christmas carol that wasn’t religious,” she told Classic FM. The music came first, and the words followed.

What she wrote is a melody almost anyone can learn on first hearing. It moves by step, rarely leaping, in a single line that a whole room could pick up by the second verse. That simplicity is deliberate. A carol is a song a community sings together, and Wallen built one that doesn’t need a believer, a trained voice, or a printed program to join.

The wrong note

Bruegel painting of hunters returning through snow above a valley of frozen ponds and skaters
Pieter Bruegel the Elder, The Hunters in the Snow, 1565. Kunsthistorisches Museum, Vienna (public domain).

Under that plain tune, something doesn’t quite settle. The accompaniment rings with bell-like figures, and here and there it rubs against the melody in a small dissonance that never fully resolves. Wallen has said she wanted it to hold both the darkness of winter and the hope of light.

That unease is the reason the carol belongs in a concert called Darkness & Light. Most Christmas music arrives already consoled. Peace on Earth asks for peace from inside a winter that is still cold and uncertain, and lets you hear both at once. The bells and the wrong note sound together, the way the season does for many people.

From King’s to the King

The carol reached a wide audience when the Choir of King’s College, Cambridge recorded it in 2019 under Stephen Cleobury, and it returned in their Festival of Nine Lessons and Carols in 2022. About twenty artists recorded it within a couple of years, and it has been translated into Catalan.

In August 2024 Wallen was appointed Master of the King’s Music, succeeding Judith Weir in a post that dates to 1626. She was already the first woman to win an Ivor Novello Award for a body of classical work, and the first Black woman to have a piece performed at the BBC Proms. A song that began in her own songbook now belongs to choirs everywhere, including this one.

Hear it in December

Ars Nova Singers men, in black, singing from their music folders with holiday lights behind them
Ars Nova Singers.

Darkness & Light: A Solstice Celebration
Ars Nova Singers, Tom Morgan, Artistic Director, with Gavin Kitchen, vibraphone and percussion

  • Thursday, December 10, 2026, 7:30 pm: United Church of Christ, 1500 9th Avenue, Longmont
  • Sunday, December 13, 2026, 3:00 pm: St. Paul Center for Music and the Arts, 1600 Grant Street, Denver, and by livestream
  • Thursday, December 17, 2026, 7:30 pm: Mountain View United Methodist Church, 355 Ponca Place, Boulder
  • Saturday, December 19, 2026, 7:30 pm: Mountain View United Methodist Church, 355 Ponca Place, Boulder

Adult tickets are $40. Students and youth 18 and under attend free, because live choral music belongs to the next generation too. Livestream tickets for the Denver performance are $35. Read more: A Drop of the Sea, a Star of the Sea.

Reference notes

Similar Posts